What Tasmanian workplaces told us about WHS honesty
We recently asked people what gets in the way of WHS honesty. The leading answer was scary; fear of blame, consequences or being targeted. Read more about the reality of WHS honesty in the workplace.


Earlier this year, I asked workers, leaders, business owners, WHS professionals and regulators a fairly simple question:
In your experience, what is the biggest thing that gets in the way of people being completely honest about WHS?
We asked the question across our LinkedIn network, the 2026 WorkSafe Tasmania Conference in Hobart and Launceston, and the 2026 TMEC Conference.
Across the three conference groups alone, 102 people responded and the results confirmed something my gut had been telling me for a while.
People do not “hide” the truth because they are difficult, recalcitrant or reckless.
They do it because they are making a calculation. A risk assessment:
Will I be heard?
Will anything change? How much benefit could I achieve,
And what is the personal risk if I say the thing? How much could this blow back on me?
Fear was the clear leader
Of the 102 conference respondents:
42.2% said fear of blame, consequences or being targeted was the biggest barrier to honesty.
18.6% pointed to the pressure of balancing safety with other operational demands.
15.7% said procedures or expectations did not match the reality of the work.
11.8% believed speaking up would fall on deaf ears.
7.8% said the expected answer felt safer than the honest one.
The remaining 2.9% selected “other”.
Fear was especially prominent at the WorkSafe Tasmania Conference, selected by 42.9% of respondents in Hobart and 47.6% in Launceston.
At TMEC, the picture shifted slightly. Operational demands ranked first at 33.3%, followed by fear at 27.8% and the belief that speaking up would fall on deaf ears at 22.2%.
That difference matters.
It suggests that although fear is a significant issue across Tasmanian workplaces, the pressures shaping honesty are not identical everywhere. In operational environments, the immediate tension between keeping work moving and raising a WHS concern may be just as influential as the fear of what happens after someone speaks.
The written responses told us even more
The comments added context that a graph never could.
People spoke about:
Being labelled a “snitch” or safety being treated as uncool.
Production pressure taking priority.
Being shut down or not listened to.
WHS being treated as somebody else’s responsibility.
Procedures that did not reflect how work could actually be done.
Concerns being raised but disappearing into a black hole.
Work not being designed around the people expected to perform it.
There were positive examples too, including leaders who actively encouraged people to disclose what was really happening.
But the dominant theme was clear: people were not always unwilling to speak up. They were deciding whether speaking up was worth it.
Caring about safety does not guarantee that you know the truth
This is the uncomfortable part.
A leader can care deeply about WHS and still only be getting half the story. You can have an open-door policy. You can tell people to report hazards. You can genuinely believe that nobody will be blamed for speaking up.
But honesty is not created by what leaders say they want. It is shaped by what people experience when they test it.
What happens when someone raises an issue less than politely? When they are frustrated, emotional, blunt or struggling to articulate themselves?
Does the concern still get heard, or does everyone become distracted by how it was delivered?
What happens after the conversation? Does the person get an update, even when the answer is no? Or does their concern disappear into a meeting, spreadsheet or action list, never to be mentioned again?
What happens when the “safety procedure” bears little resemblance to the work?
If the official response is always “follow the procedure”, while everyone knows the procedure is unworkable, people learn to stop telling you about the trade-offs, workarounds and judgement calls keeping the job moving. The messy reality of work. They give you the socially safe answer.
An open door is not enough
Honesty is shaped by leadership behaviour, power, competing demands, previous experiences and whether people believe telling the truth will lead somewhere useful.
The answer is not another “speak up” campaign.
Leaders need to look at the conditions surrounding the conversation:
Are people safe to say the thing, warts and all?
Do people see evidence that their voices count?
Do procedures help people make good decisions, or describe an imaginary version of the work?
Have overloaded leaders been given the time and headspace to actually listen?
Can people talk honestly about the messy reality of work; the risk, trade-offs and imperfect environments, without judgement or fear?
Good WHS systems support these conditions. They make expectations clearer. They make ownership and follow-through visible. They establish the hard lines while still giving people room to use judgement when work does not unfold neatly.
Most importantly, they help leaders stay connected to work as it is done, not simply work as it appears in the procedure.
Without true warts and all honesty from your people, you are flying blind.......and the most dangerous part is that you may not even know it.
Want to take a closer look at what shapes honesty in your workplace? Download our practical guide, What Stops Workers Being Honest About WHS?.
